Join an online community of 132,912 people. Create a profile, make new friends, share pictures and videos with the 133 people online now!

Subscribe | Back to Social Issues

So I had a thought

Tell people about this topic:
+ Post Reply

Total Posts: 15 Posts

  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 2:14 am

    about death. A controversial one I guess. It came to me after a conversation I had with a friend about cancer.
    Say we found a cure for cancer, fanastic right? Everyone that would have died from cancer would still be alive. And what about if we found a way to prevent ALL unnecessary deaths from occuring? Everyone that would have died from road accidents, murders, and sickness would still be alive. We would just die from old age and...that's it. We and all our friends and relatives would all live their full lives. Sounds wonderful.
    But do you think that pretty soon the earth would become literally over-crowded if we were to prevent all deaths but old age? I think it definetely would. So are all these unnecessary deaths really unnecessary? Saying that, should we stop trying to find a cure for cancer?
    But of course intial reaction to that question would be that of the person asking it is heartless presenting a 'thining the crowd' idea.
    What do you think?

    Last edited by Amelia., Tue 26th Aug 2008, 2:22 am.

    Amelia.

    18, Female, UK

    555 Posts
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 2:33 am

    It would become overcrowded obviously, there would be more births than deaths. Buttt I'm guessing if it did happen, there'd be plans to stop the population increasing like the one child policy would be brought into other countries and stuff.
    What would happen with suicide?


    Melissa.

    Account removed
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 3:31 am

    There are already way more births than deaths.

    Check this out.

    All deaths are necessary in all honesty. Its just some deaths, like through cancer, are a pretty horrible way to die.


    Himmler

    Account removed
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 4:55 am

    Amelia. wrote:
    What do you think?

    its shit. also, who cares? some things we have no control over.


    Firstname

    21, Male, UK

    46 Posts
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 10:37 am
    No we should not stop looking for a cure from cancer, I'm assuming you've never been effected by cancer or that no one you know has either? I find your opinions pretty sick!

    Alison100

    Account removed
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 12:02 pm

    Alison100 wrote:

    No we should not stop looking for a cure from cancer, I'm assuming you've never been effected by cancer or that no one you know has either? I find your opinions pretty sick!

    I dont think she meant it like that. Its a what if question

    OT: It would be overcrowded and therefore problems such as poverty would increase.

    Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order and everything becomes chaos. I'm an agent of chaos. Oh and you know the thing about chaos? It's fair.


  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 2:00 pm

    Alison100 wrote:

    No we should not stop looking for a cure from cancer, I'm assuming you've never been effected by cancer or that no one you know has either? I find your opinions pretty sick!

    You have blatently misunderstood. Re-read and try again.


    Amelia.

    18, Female, UK

    555 Posts
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 2:17 pm
    Deaths are a necessary part of life, if people stopped dying before they were old, the world would become overcrowded, boring to a certain extent (imagine knowing everyone would live till 85...) Id rather actually die young then wait till some of the old age conditions take over .. eg needing someone to help you go to bed, toilet etc.



    Hiro

    25, Male, AL

    2,902 Posts
  • Report | Quote Posted: Tue 26th Aug 2008, 3:06 pm
    Then you would get into a situation to what they had in Logans Run... and they're solution wasnt particularly grand now was it.

    http://i111.photobucket.com/albums/n124/TragicCollapse/Woodgate.jpg


  • Report | Quote Posted: Fri 5th Sep 2008, 10:33 pm

    Amelia. wrote:

    about death. A controversial one I guess. It came to me after a conversation I had with a friend about cancer.
    Say we found a cure for cancer, fanastic right? Everyone that would have died from cancer would still be alive. And what about if we found a way to prevent ALL unnecessary deaths from occuring? Everyone that would have died from road accidents, murders, and sickness would still be alive. We would just die from old age and...that's it. We and all our friends and relatives would all live their full lives. Sounds wonderful.
    But do you think that pretty soon the earth would become literally over-crowded if we were to prevent all deaths but old age? I think it definetely would. So are all these unnecessary deaths really unnecessary? Saying that, should we stop trying to find a cure for cancer?
    But of course intial reaction to that question would be that of the person asking it is heartless presenting a 'thining the crowd' idea.
    What do you think?

    exactly everything is here for a reason because of medication and cures there isint any natural selection anymore...so the weaker race are living on and crowding the population breeding and making more weaker breeds... but thats life how it is i guess...

    :D :inlove2: http://oOTaMzOo.bebo.com :inlove2: :D

    lushMUCH

    20, Female, UK

    1,410 Posts
  • Report | Quote Posted: Fri 5th Sep 2008, 10:40 pm
    A large part of the inhabited parts of Earth are already overcrowded

    No1Toker

    Account removed
  • Report | Quote Posted: Fri 5th Sep 2008, 10:47 pm
    the minute you start having thoughts like this...should be followed by a minute when you think "wtf??! life's a lottery. I'm off to the pub..."

    Dee

    Account removed
  • Report | Quote Posted: Sat 6th Sep 2008, 9:19 pm

    No1Toker wrote:

    A large part of the inhabited parts of Earth are already overcrowded

    Yes.

    Also death seems to have evolved with organisms from the most basic protein strands to full fledged organisms such as ourselves. A gene vehicle (such as ourselves) is liable to become sick, injured or consumed by another organism, and the odds of this increase with time. An efficient biological process therefore is to keep us carriers alive long enough to reproduce, but not long enough that when our bodies become defective and free-radicals build up we're still capable of passing on sub-standard genetic information. Therefore death is a good way of ensuing healtyh genes are passed on. It just so happens human's developed this thing called consciousness and therefore can understand and fear our future experiation, unlike other animals who live only in the present. We're lucky that being a large mammal our lifespan on average is pretty good and measured in decades rather than months, weeks or even days.

    If death is genetic, then one day we may be able to alter our DNA in such a way as to stop the ageing process at a desired time, or perhaps possess nanontechnology sufficient enough to repair and halt it. That said it would probably be a luxury afforded only by the very rich (if the concept of monetary transfer still exists at the time), and humanity would have to have escaped the cradle of the Earth in order to handle such an event.

    1337 []D05te|2

    Dr. Nobody wrote:

    Things were rocky and then when we finally decided to get intimate, I discovered something very unexpected. Apparently, she hasn't finished her "transformation" and still has a penis. Now I love her even more.


  • Report | Quote Posted: Sat 6th Sep 2008, 9:27 pm
    I spoke about this with my brother the other day actually...I think there is alot more cures than we could even contemplate but this would cause the population to increase and increase and things like fossil fuels etc are running out as it is...So i think they prefer not to release these cures...

    supermanyeh wrote:

    I love it when i cum in a birds mouth and then she spits it into mine, then i gargle with it, and spit it back into hers for her to swallow


  • Report | Quote Posted: Sat 6th Sep 2008, 9:36 pm
    Damned government suppression, I noes they've got zero-point energy really!!!!1

    1337 []D05te|2

    Dr. Nobody wrote:

    Things were rocky and then when we finally decided to get intimate, I discovered something very unexpected. Apparently, she hasn't finished her "transformation" and still has a penis. Now I love her even more.


+ Post Reply

So I had a thought

Discuss So I had a thought on the Mingleville Social Issues message forum